Allison Gale
Professor Brown
English 1B
18 February 2013
A Grim
Future for Generations Y and Z;
And The Glory of Escapism
It’s hard for me to talk about this without feeling a
small sense of hopelessness. I watch the youth of today strolling around campus
and elsewhere and really feel empathy for their cause. They have an unyielding road
ahead of them. When I say “today’s youth” I’m referring to Generations Y and Z.
Generation Y is defined as people born
in or after 1980 (Geck 2). Youths born in or after 1990 are members of the
newest net generation (Geck 1). This “net generation” is often called
Generation Z and they have a cloudy destiny awaiting them. No generation has
suffered more from the Great Recession than the young. Median net worth of
people under 35, according to U.S. Census, fell 37 percent between 2005 and
2010; those over 65 only took a 13 percent hit (Girod, Shapiro 2). In other words the baby boomers, those
between the ages of 48 and 66, have set up an ugly world for the young. Our
economy is at its worst since the Great Depression. Terrorism is still quite
prevalent and has dramatically changed our way of living. There are threats of
nuclear attacks from North Korea and Iran. And now, even meteors are falling
from the sky and have become an actual threat! So not only do Generation Y and
Z have these terrifying things to contemplate and face, they have to go to
school and then try to find
Gale
2
work and be
positive about their future! But even that is virtually impossible. Their
indebted parents are not leaving their jobs, forcing younger people to put
careers on hold. Since 2008 the percentage of the workforce under 25 has
dropped 13.2 percent, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, while that
of people over 55 has risen by 7.6 percent (Girod, Shapiro 2). So with all this
in mind, it’s safe to say that the reason these kids are trying to escape from
reality isn’t because they are selfish and detached, as some have said; but
because of an ever growing need to forget about the real world for a bit. Some
call it “escapism” but I like to refer to it as “weathering the storm”.
So what are a few of the most faddish escaping tools?
There is the Internet and those fancy new smart phones which allow access to
entertainment and information at all times. I swear, wherever I go, if I see a
person between the ages of 18-34; they have some sort of electronic device in
their hands. With this in mind, I’ve been watching a steady prominence in the
appreciation of video games and comic books amongst men, and even women. Most
young males spend a great amount of time playing fantasy/science fiction, comic
book related or war inspired video games. The delinquency charge has now been
passed on to the new media kid on the block: the video game (Ndalianis 1). This genre is a multi-billion dollar industry
and growing. My fiancé is 32 and can’t wait to get home to play the latest
Spiderman or Call of Duty game! He says it’s “his way of forgetting about an
awful day at work, when he makes little to no money”. Young adults are being
heavily criticized for their great affection for violent and graphic video
games. Some say that this constant feed of violence into the minds of the youth
is even the cause of some underlying emotional issues and current shooting
tragedies. But I believe it’s a way to forget about the cruel world which is
surrounding us. It’s a way to escape and live a
Gale
3
different life for a
brief moment in time. But mostly, I see the ever growing fascination with
celebrities as the biggest escape mechanism to date. From gossip magazines such
as “In Style” to the MTV Music Video Awards, we are being inundated with images
of the rich and elite; and we buy into it hook, line and sinker! And with this,
our younger generations are aspiring to live these privileged lives and become
stars like them. Look at the success of shows such as “American Idol” and “The
Voice”. Why does it seem like everyone is trying to be a star or emulate one? Is
the crushing success of music stars a characteristic of hidden emotional
problems with our younger demographics?
A
fantastic example of this is a New York gal named Stefani Angelina Germanotta.
She was reborn Lady Gaga in a New Jersey Parsippany studio in 2006 (Peters 1).
Gaga is a wildly popular and controversial artist that is the perfect ideal of
the “worshipped star”. Most of the older generations don’t get her and they
probably never will. But she continues in her success mostly because of her
“Little Monster” followers. These groupies consist mainly of the Generations Y
and Z groups and are being criticized for their worship of Gaga. Some even are
calling it a “cult” type following and are majorly concerned that she is a poor
influence on today’s younger adults. Broad groups of people of ages 50 and
older find her repulsive. Whether it is because of her unconventional costumes,
the crazy things she says or the radical concerts she puts on; they can’t stand
her. And so some may ask, is this type of following indicative of the emotional
caliber of our younger generations? I would absolutely have to disagree if
anyone said it was. Humans have been interested in the arts and the
controversial scene that comes with it for centuries. This whole thing is
nothing new and to call it anything more than common interest is
Gale
4
absurd. She is merely
an artist that has a strong following of other artisans desiring to be just
like their mentor.
There
are several examples of previous conflicts when addressing controversial
artists. One I found particularly interesting was written by Michael A. Peters.
He is a prominent author that states: Gaga, ca-ca (toddler talk) by an obvious
association reminds me of Dada and Dadaism, the cultural movement that began in
Switzerland in the period 1916-22 with Hugo Ball and others involving
experiments across the visual arts, literature, especially poetry, art
manifestoes, art theory, theatre and graphic design. It included public
gatherings, demonstrations, and publications of art/literary journals and
influenced styles like the avant-garde and downtown music movements, and the
groups including surrealism, Nouveau realism, pop art, Fluxus and punk rock. It
was decidedly anti-bourgeois and anarchist in nature (1). This is a considerable
argument to show that the extreme admiration of celebrities and their culture
is indeed nothing out of the ordinary. Lady Gaga is simply the unusual
performing artist of the moment that is getting the finger pointed at her by conservative
nit pickers. Gaga is just thinking outside the box and trying to make a living.
To criticize and belittle Lady Gaga and her “Little Monsters” is hurtful to the
message that she sends out. I believe that being true to yourself and candidly
embracing being “Born This Way” is a positive cannonball that shouldn’t be
negatively viewed. Rather than saying these “Little Monsters” are bizarre and
deluded in adoring a unique woman; wouldn’t it be more prudent to accept the
fact that maybe all they need is a little evasion from the stressful world they
inhabit? In other words, escapism is not an emotional disorder but rather a way
to survive the drastic changes our world is undergoing?
Gale
5
Others
seem to think that Generations Y and Z are adopting all these ways to escape
because of other factors. I have heard them called selfish, detached and even
rude! “Young people are coddled long after they should start learning that they
aren’t perfect” That was the conclusion of HS, a blogger commenting on an
article in The New York Times lamenting the state of today’s youth. “The
trouble with kids is that they have an overinflated opinion of themselves
because they have been brought up to believe that everything they do is
valuable and important”. This was no grumpy old codger, but a young man writing
about his own generation (Spinney 1). Spinney goes on to say; Generation Me has
drawn some flak. Its members stand accused of being spoiled, arrogant and
narcissistic, with an underserved sense of entitlement. College professors
complain that today’s students demand constant attention. Employers find is
hard to stomach the overblown egos of their young recruits, and therapists say
they’re seeing a new generation of patients depressed because they are unable
to live up to their own excessive expectations (2). I partially agree with what
was said here. I have noticed a trend in their withdrawing from society and a
noticeable angst towards others when reacting to their environment. I am a very
friendly person and being back on campus I notice that most of the younger
demographics don’t seem too interested in interaction. They’re either on their
phones or tablets and I have only met a few that wish to openly chat with me. They
distance themselves and almost do seem “distanced” or “rude”. But I do not
believe it’s because they want to be like this and don’t want to engage with
me. Just like I stated before, this is a horrible world we are living in now. They
don’t have a choice but to act like they are self-entitled and arrogant.
Sometimes keeping to your self can come off that way. I was born in 1976 and am
almost twice the age of most of the other students on campus. I come from
Generation X and had a very
Gale
6
affluent upbringing in
the 80’s and 90’s. That’s probably why I’m so gregarious all the time! On the
contrary, I feel like these generations have been backed into a corner. They
are on the defense daily to protect themselves from all the craziness out there.
It’s truly difficult to trust anyone now-a-days! With the competition out there
for jobs and the increasing safety threats, Generations Y and Z really have no
choice but to act protective and disassociated. It’s a dog eat dog world now
more than ever and being brutally confident and apprehensive is not the same
thing as being narcissistic and arrogant.
In
closing I see this growing trend of escapism as a defense mechanism. Considering
that the one’s critiquing the “Little Monsters” and anyone else displaying
their love of Gaga and other controversial celebrities are the older
generations; they should try to remember that these “kids” are merely looking
for someone to inspire them in an uninspiring world. According to all the scary
statistics; the older generations are the reason that Generations Y and Z are
struggling to find some sort of release from the stress of modern times. The
screwed generation also enters adulthood loaded down by a mountain of boomer
and senior incurred debt; debt that spirals ever more out of control (Girad,
Shapiro 4). My fiancé is often referred to as delusional and childish for his
love of video games. And I have to admit, he is kind of a gigantic child!
However, I see it as his coping method to stop thinking about how he’s going to
pay all our bills this month because work was so slow. Does this mean that he
has emotional problems because he likes shooting aliens on a big HD television?
Absolutely not; and nor would he ever hurt anyone in real life. He just doesn’t
want to grow up entirely because really, what is there to look forward to? We
can’t afford to have a baby right now. We might never be able to have one with
the way the economy looks! Inevitably, young people are delaying their leap
into adulthood. Nearly a
Gale
7
third of people between
18 and 34 have put off marriage or having a baby due to the recession (Girod,
Shapiro 4) In addition, is it so wrong that a crude and contentious performer
like Gaga be so heavily criticized for her following of today’s youth? Once
again, I would have to say no. These young adults and teenagers are desperately
seeking out some sort of release to deal with the pressure of living and
hopefully succeeding in this astringent world. I really do sympathize for them
and can only hope that things improve. Banning video games and censoring
sexually explicit performers is not the answer to helping the future of
Generations Y and Z. The older generations need to accept the fact that times
are changing and to stop being so stubborn and critical. Maybe instead of
constantly slamming these young adults for how they act or who they follow, they
should actually help them in some way. Stop complaining about the current rise
in sales tax to help our schools. Instead of buying that new Lexus or boat,
donate to your local college. Next time you’re out to eat with all your rich
friends, tip your waiter 25% in place of 15%. In this world, it’s the little
things that are going to help us move forward. And I pray that these new
generations get all the help we can give to see our society through the stormy
times ahead.
Commentary #1: Allison on the “Glory of Escapism”
ReplyDeleteI agree with Allison on her views of my generation and our methods of escapism. The recession, amongst other things, has forced my generation to try and forget the real world for a bit. Day after day, we’re told to be positive about our future, and to find work. These things are tossed back into our face as we realize that with the current economy, the job market for kids my age is very difficult to get into(as I’ve learned), and getting a job now requires having connections in management and whatnot. The real world, to us, is a place with mostly dim prospects.
So, our only real way to escape that, if only for a little while, is through games, books, and music. I feel like Allison outlined that quite well in her essay, especially through her exploration of how young guys my age tend to lean more towards videogaming and comic books. I also liked how she was able to connect her essay to Lady Gaga, and how the feel of belonging in a group, such as Gaga’s “little monsters”, lends to our escapes from the real world. I’m not a fan of all of Gaga’s music(I only like certain songs), but I do appreciate the message she puts out into the world: basically, love yourself. You were born a certain way, and you’ve got to learn to love yourself for who you are. I think that’s a really touching message to this generation.
In my generation, I see a lot of self-hate, especially amongst girls my age. It’s a sad thing to see, especially with society pushing forward these norms that every girl must be perfect and look like Kim Kardashian. I think Gaga’s message is a good counterargument to this.
All in all, I believe Allison’s analysis of our escapism was well-researched. However, it could use a bit more elaboration on music and the internet, specifically blogging websites. Those two tend to be the biggest sources of escapism that we have. Another critical point would be the counterargument. The essay lacks that, and I feel that when one is added, her argument will be even stronger.